Mission to Learn – Lifelong Learning Blog
Follow Us!
Screen Capture from Carnegie Hall Web site - Deliberate Practice Practice Practice

8 Keys to Deliberate Practice.

A New Yorker (or in some versions Arthur Rubinstein) is approached in the street near Carnegie Hall, and asked, “Pardon me sir, how do I get to Carnegie Hall?” He replies, “Practice, practice, practice.” (Wikipedia)

We’ve all heard the old Carnegie Hall joke (well, at least those of us above a certain age have). More recently, you may have caught the buzz about the importance of “10,000 hours” as popularized by Malcom Gladwell in Outliers. The message in both cases it that if you really want to excel at something, a lot of time and a lot of practice are required.

The time part seems straightforward enough, but I know from my own love/hate experience with learning the guitar over many years that simply clocking hours of practice is not enough. The practice has to be of a certain quality. As Anders Ericsson has argued in his body of work on the topic, it has to be deliberate practice.

I found an interesting take on the concept of deliberate practice a while back in an article on “expert performance” in the Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal. I recommend the full article. If you can motivate yourself to read and take notes on the whole thing (it is, as might be expected, a bit long and academic), I think you will find some great wisdom in it. You don’t have to consider yourself an entrepreneur to benefit from the insights – they apply broadly.

Whether or not you read the whole thing, here are eight key features of deliberate practice as it is discussed in the article. I’ve provided my own gloss on each:

1. Deliberate practice is highly demanding mentally, requiring high levels of focus and concentration.
You’ve heard it before – no pain, no gain. But the authors also stress that you have to be “fully absorbed” in your practice for it to truly be effective.

2. It is designed specifically to improve performance—to strengthen it beyond its current levels.
This is the part that says you can’t just put in time and expect to get significantly better at anything – you have to consistently stretch yourself, and then stretch some more.

3. It must continue for long of periods of time.
This is Gladwell’s 10,000 hours/10 years. The authors go on to say “Basic research on expert performance suggests that the benefits it generates cannot usually be attained with less than 10 years of continued, vigorous effort (e.g., Ericsson, 2006).”

4. It must be repeated.
Even though repetition alone won’t get you to the level of excellence, you also won’t get there without out it. Perhaps this why the word “Practice” is repeated three times in the old joke.

5. It requires continuous feedback on results.
Sometimes you can tell on your own whether you are doing things right. I know when I hit a wrong note on the guitar, for example. But very often this is the area where having a great teacher, coach, or mentor can make all the difference.

6. Pre-performance preparation is essential.
This is where goal setting comes in – you have to know where you want to go if you expect to get there. And as the authors stress, goal-setting “should involve not merely outcomes, but also the processes involved in reaching predetermined goals.”

7. It involves self-observation and self-reflection.
As you practice, you need to be continually aware of your own performance and be focused on correcting and adapting as appropriate.  This kind of in-the-moment self-assessment is critical regardless of whether a teacher is involved.

8. It involves careful reflection on performance after practice sessions are completed.
In addition to being aware of your performance as you are practicing, you need to look back on it once you are done and determine where you stand with respect to your overall goals. What might you change the next time to ensure ongoing progress? (And see my thoughts on reflection as a learning habit.)

The overall focus of this article is on entrepreneurship, but regardless of whether you are an entrepreneur, I think you will find many insights here that are useful to practice in your particular area of interest. Given that “entrepreneurship” is a somewhat fuzzy area, however, the article may be especially helpful to you if you are pursuing interests that are not as straightforward as learning a musical instrument or a new language.

How does deliberate practice factor in to your learning habits? Please comment and share with other readers.

Jeff

P.S. – Also be sure to check out why deliberate practice may not be enough.

About the Author Jeff Cobb

I am an avid lifelong learner who writes and speaks frequently on the critical role of learning in our fast-changing world.

follow me on:

Leave a Comment:

35 comments
Jeff Cobb says

Daniel – Thanks for commenting. I agree it would be misleading, which is why I do not claim that in the article. Nor do any of the sources. “10,000 hours” is generally viewed as necessary, but not sufficient for achieving excellence. I recognize also that there are exceptions, but as it usually the case, those only tend to prove the rule.

You may also want to see: https://www.missiontolearn.com/2011/11/why-practice-practice-practice-may-not-get-you-to-carnegie-hall/

Jeff

Reply
Daniel Marks says

And 1 more thing,what about all the prodigies who were expert at some difficult task by the time they were 4 years old? Kinda dispells the 10 year theory!

Reply
Daniel Marks says

I think it is misleading to tell individuals they can become expert at anything,and that congenital factors can not limit them.When you consider the facts, the concept of all individuals having the same ultimate potential becomes impossible to endorse. Theres a lot going around about this 10 000 hour deliberate practice business,but other research suggests most people who do 10 000 hours of deliberate practice do not acheive expertise as a result.
Why is it that we all accept outright that once you are over a certain age,it is impossible to pursue elite sport such as tennis or football.We understand that age produces certain changes within the body that simply forbid us performing in a way that a young person can.No system of effort or strategy can overcome this.We accept that once these changes have taken place,it is all over. Now consider that congenital and genetic factors produce differences in a human mind and body which are no less significant than the differences between young and old individuals.Why is it impossible to accept that these differences place absolute boundaries on what level we can perform at,just as we know that optimism or perserverence can not counter the effects of age and the biological changes it brings? There is absolutely no trainer in the world who will take on a 50 year old swimming student,simply because they know there are biological factors that mean the individual will simply be able to perform to standard.They know they are wasting their time.
Why would it be different for young people with varying degrees of neurological and physiological development?

Reply
Why are some people are more driven than others?? | says

[…] your craft for thousands of hours until you’re a master. This gels with Ericsson‘s work on deliberate practice, and the well-known (thanks to Malcolm Gladwell) idea that it takes 10,000 hours of deliberate […]

Reply
Jeff Cobb says

I’m not convinced we can, George. The motivation for deliberate practice has to be intrinsic – at least at its core. We can help people find their motivation, and once they have found it, support them in pursuing it. If we can inspire them, it is probably only through our own example. My two cents. – Jeff

Reply
George Lowe says

I agree with all 8 points made above. My question is how do we inspire people to practice deliberately? Most of the things above don’t sound that fun…

Reply
Waktu « I Learn How to Be says

[…] Proses ini harus dilakukan dengan fokus dan konsentrasi yang optimal. Lengkapnya, sila kunjungi ini. Jadi, aku menghargai waktu sebagai upaya pencarian dan pengasahan expertise. Aku tak ingin […]

Reply
The Best Resources For Learning About The 10,000 Hour Rule & Deliberative Practice | Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day… says

[…] How Do You Get to Carnegie Hall? 8 Keys to Deliberate Practice. is from Mission to Learn. […]

Reply
Katherine Gordy Levine says

Pinned your blog. pinterest.com/pin/147141112796008442/ Good luck.

Reply
Impatience « Asrai Devin- the Maven of Mischief says

[…] you the patient type who can easily spend their time putting in their 10,000 hours of practice to reach excellence? Or would you rather find a magic lamp tomorrow and suddenly have success […]

Reply
Day 04 Daily interpreting practice | Interpretings says

[…] if you practice? Are interpreters born or made? In cognitive psychology there is a concept called deliberate practice. Deliberate practice a common denominator for experts, it means that you not only practice […]

Reply
The Pebble in Your Shoe says

[…] from years of the daily grind (both hard work and “smart” work). It’s all about deliberate practice in whatever field you wish to master. So it’s not about some grand plans or undertakings. […]

Reply
Snowboarding Camp Wrap-up: Goals, Reflection, & Recognition | Carrie Cheadle, M.A., CC-AASP says

[…] A key skill to develop if you really want to drive your performance forward and improve is to have goal-directed practice. Setting goals before practice helps you be deliberate about what you want to improve and how you […]

Reply
Coffeescript, Jasmine and Katas | Caffeine Industries says

[…] also become a believer in dedicated, deliberate practice. One can constantly reuse the same patterns and never really push themselves to get better. […]

Reply
(Schijn) zekerheden | Gevoel voor Verkoop says

[…] las pas geleden een heel interessant stuk dat ging over het fenomeen ‘delibrate practice’ oftewel opzettelijk oefenen. Dat wil zoveel zeggen dat als je iets nieuws wil leren je niet […]

Reply
The Ovecoming Anxiety Project says

[…] Spend a minimum of 5 hours per week on “deliberate practice” relating to overcoming anxiety and depression.  That may involve getting various types of […]

Reply
Waktu « embodying reality says

[…] Proses ini harus dilakukan dengan fokus dan konsentrasi yang optimal. Lengkapnya, sila kunjungi ini. Jadi, aku menghargai waktu sebagai upaya pencarian dan pengasahan expertise. Aku tak ingin […]

Reply
Exam results – what to do if you fail! « Pedleysmiths's Blog says

[…] just practice that matters but how you practice, you need to practice deliberately. He calls it deliberate practice and it […]

Reply
David K Waltz says

I have just blogged about the same topic the past two days! I used an article by K. Anders Ericsson.

The thing that intrigued me about the linked article was that there was a section on expert teams.

At one time I was looking into incentive mechanisms for individuals and teams and ran across an article that was critical of the practice of rotating “star” or “high potential” folks through different positions. This article noted that the best indicator of team performance was length of time it had spent together. This seems like another way of saying that for a team to become expert it needs to spend 10,000 hours together.

Nice post, thank you.

Reply
Edward L. Gober says

As a former competitive athlete, where repetition is critical, and now a competitive business man I firmly support the seventh key feature in this offering.

By repeatedly placing yourself in situations (10,00 hours) you will face on the playing field or the board room you gain awareness of situations that will arise allowing yourself to assess and “switch gears” in the moment.

Whether you believe there is a “choke effect” or an “in the zone effect”, I personally believe you can avoid the first and summons the latter by being conscious of the moment you are in and making the proper adjustments immediately.

Reply
Flow and Strategy (also a draft) « On the Path, Off the Trail says

[…] would also like to post this article which summarizes this essay on what it takes to have deliberate practice. The 8 Key features […]

Reply
Jeff Cobb says

Denis – Thanks for commenting. I think the difference between practice and performance is critical. Obviously, I’m just reporting on the research here, but I agree with the researchers that self-observation and reflection during and after practice are critical. During actual performance, on the other hand – and it is performance that Lehrer addresses – “second guessing the skills that have been honed through years of diligent practice” can indeed lead to choking. – Jeff

Reply
Denis says

An interesting read, but the 7th point is doubtable:

7. It involves self-observation and self-reflection.
As you practice, you need to be continually aware of your own performance and be focused on correcting and adapting as appropriate. This kind of in-the-moment self-assessment is critical regardless of whether a teacher is involved.

I remember teachers, my karate trainer telling me that I had to go there and perform, not analyzing too much inside the experience. Have you heard about the “choke” effect described by Jonah Lehrer in the book “How we decide”, I guess?

Doing your homework and post-analysis are important, thinking too much while you perform may “choke” you.

Reply
Nolo Promittere says

Tony Buzan iterated much of this with his TEFCAS model of learning – Trials, Events, Feedback, Checks, Adjustments and Success. He doesn’t talk of 10,000 hours of practice though.

Reply
Vitamins for memory – good practice makes a perfect memory « Vitamins for Memory says

[…] Note: Even though the memories of Anders Ericsson’s students look like those of experts, they are not. Remember, to become an expert in any field, one needs at least 10,000 hours of practice (about 10 years). But just rehearsing is not the way to become a world champion. Deliberate practice is the key, found Anders Ericsson. Read more about how to become an expert here. […]

Reply
How to become an expert « evitaminsformemory says

[…] for my next post on memory techniques on the Vitamins for Memory blog, I came across this very interesting article on deliberate practice. Deliberate practice has – amongst […]

Reply
The Start of a Ten Year Journey says

[…] They say it takes 10 years/10,000 hours of deliberate practice to become an expert in an area. What better reason to pick an arbitrary date? […]

Reply
Kenneth says

Jeff..this article is very true.. i learned this from my Marketing class and my Management class. It inspired to finish my college. I have to ask you this though because it often happened to me. How do you handle the temptations like party, girls, etc. Do i have to give up those kinda stuff just to achieved my goal?

Reply
Assignment 2: Improvisation on a Theme « Ewha B-Lang says

[…] How Do You Get to Carnegie Hall? 8 Keys to Deliberate Practice. “A New Yorker… is approached in the street near Carnegie Hall, and asked, ‘Pardon me sir, how do I get to Carnegie Hall?’ He replies, ‘Practice, practice, practice.’” […]

Reply
“Talent is Overrated” « Off the blocks says

[…] we need to do is to perform “Deliberate Practice” and Colvin is at his best is laying out this concept for us, with examples. As I read I […]

Reply
Jeff Cobb says

John – I do have to wonder – as it sounds like you are – if the whole concept of practice is suffering amidst all the potential distractions we have these days. (Like reading blogs!) As your comment suggests, you definitely have to have a certain amount of faith that it will get you somewhere, even if the specifics are not always so clear. Thanks so much for sharing your thoughts. – Jeff

Reply
John Sherry says

Practice is a commitment which is getting rarer these days Jeff. You got to keep on keeping on – just ask atheletes training for the Olympics for years with no guarantee of return. Many practice only if they know what results they will get – the best practice because it’s the thing to do and will lead to achievement sometime. They just know it will lead somewhere. So, to me, practice is a form of personal dedication.

Reply
Must Reads for a Software Developer « Jason Geeks Out! says

[…] is Clean Code: A Handbook of Agile Software Craftsmanship by Robert C. Martin. If you want some deliberate practice to make you a better professional, you can’t go wrong with this […]

Reply
Add Your Reply